Insurance Claims Numbers
We hope you never have to use your insurance, but sometimes, things happen. If you need to report a claim, please view the list below.
If you’ve had a claim that is a non-emergency and would like to discuss your options, give us a call and we’d be happy to do that.
| COMPANY NAME | CLAIMS PHONE NUMBER |
|---|---|
| American Modern | (800) 543-2644 option 1 |
| American Reliable | (800) 245-1505 |
| ASI (American Strategic Insurance) | (866) 274-5677 |
| Bristol West | (800) 274-7865 |
| Dairyland | (800) 334-0090 |
| Encompass | (800) 588-7400 |
| First American | (888) 922-5344 |
| Foremost | (800) 527-3907 |
| The General | (800) 280-1466- Option 3 |
| Hagerty | (800) 385-0274 |
| Hallmark | (800) 486-5616 option 1 |
| The Hartford AARP Customers | (877) 805-9918 |
| The Hartford Non-AARP Customers | (800) 243-5860 |
| Homeowners Of America | (866) 407-9896 |
| Kemper | (866) 675-3345 option 6 |
| Kemper Specialty | (888) 253-7834 |
| Mapfre | (877) 627-3735 |
| Mercury | (800) 503-3724 |
| National General | (800) 325-1088 |
| Nationwide | (800) 421-3535 |
| Progressive Auto | (800) 274-4499 |
| Progressive Renters | (844) 641-0816 |
| Progressive Roadside Assistance | (800) 776-2778 |
| Safeco | (800) 332-3226 |
| State Auto | (800) 766-1853 |
| State Auto - Glass Claims | (888) 504-4527 |
| Statewide | (800) 228-1710 x 925 |
| Stillwater | (800) 220-1351 |